All stories · Hot News
A Shopify seller says a conversion-rate drop was a counting gap
On August 31, Shopify seller @jlarkin353 said on X that they spent a week looking for the cause of a falling conversion rate and found it in the report. The report counted 331 completed checkouts for the day, but the seller had 600.
Share: WhatsApp · Telegram · X · Facebook · LinkedIn · Email
Conversion rate is orders divided by visits, so it can fall for three reasons: fewer orders, more visits from people who never buy, or a report that counts incorrectly.
Only the first reason means that the store is losing sales.
John Larkin@jlarkin353For the last week I’ve been trying to figure out why my conversion. Rate has dropped off a cliff. Turns out @shopify is just retsrded. It’s giving me 2% conversion but only calculating it on 331 completed checkouts instead of the 600 so far today.
Man. Sort your shit out @shopify it’s simple math.Aug 31, 2026 · View on X
Each example below comes from one store or one post.
- A report that counts incorrectly: @jlarkin353 saw a conversion rate of 2% and worked on it for a week before finding the difference in the counts. The post does not say why the report missed the other checkouts, and we could not find a public explanation from Shopify.
- Bot visits: On September 16, @itsryanlenk said that a filter marked 228 of that week's Shopify visits as bots and 172 as people. Bots add visits but not orders, so the rate falls even when sales stay the same.
- Sessions that look alike: A poster on r/ecommerce described the same pattern: traffic increased, sales did not change, and the sessions (single visits to the store) all looked alike.
- A platform problem: Some drops are real, and their cause is outside the page. On September 18, @downdetector recorded user reports of Shopify problems starting at 2:31 PM EDT.
- Shop Pay unavailable: A poster on r/ecommerce said that Shopify's status page showed Shop Pay, the Shopify fast-checkout option, as unavailable for hours.
Before you change any page, check orders and traffic separately. These are starting checks that we suggest, not a tested method:
- Look at daily orders before you look at the conversion rate.
- If orders did not change, find where the extra visits came from.
- If some hours had zero sales, check whether Shopify reported a problem at that time.
- Change pages only after orders have fallen and none of these checks explains why.
Ads Manager shows steady sales but Shopify shows a drop. Which one is correct?
The two reports count different things.
@wetracked, the account of the tracking tool wetracked.io, describes a case where ad spend doubled: Ads Manager showed twice the revenue, but Shopify did not. According to @wetracked, ad platforms also count sales from returning customers and from people who search for the brand name as ad sales. Their test: "If spend rises but total store revenue does not move, you did not scale the business."
Ad platform numbers also change after you make a decision. A poster on r/ecommerce said that Meta and Google continue to add conversions weeks later.
We suggest that you save a copy of the report on the day you decide, so you keep the numbers you actually used.
Does a higher conversion rate mean a better page?
Not always, when the traffic comes from ads.
@jforjacob sent two identical Meta ads to two different pages. For the page with the higher conversion rate, Meta also charged a higher CPM (the price per 1,000 ad impressions), so each purchase cost more. For that reason, @jforjacob tests pages inside Meta instead of with a separate split-testing (A/B) tool.
Sources · 8
- https://x.com/jlarkin353/status/2094559357161574824
- https://x.com/itsryanlenk/status/2100332149819756859
- https://www.reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1wbh7an/anyone_else_seeing_traffic_spike_with_zero/
- https://x.com/downdetector/status/2101016387095335292
- https://www.reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1wk2ehi/shop_app_shop_pay_shop_pay_installments_are/
- https://x.com/wetracked/status/2101245733106241549
- https://www.reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1wjqc37/how_are_you_handling_late_changes_to_campaign/
- https://x.com/jforjacob/status/2098123366402044312